Copyright © 2009,2010,2011,2012,2013,2014,2015,2016,2017,2018,2019,2020 Hani Fakhouri, All Rights Reserved

May 30, 2012


The Negative Results of the Egyptian Elections


For the first time in the 5,000 years of Egyptian history, more than 50 million people were eligible to vote for their first democratically elected president.  It is regrettable to say that less than half of Egyptians have exercised that right.  It has been reported that only 23.5 million Egyptians went to the polls to cast their votes.

The first winner was Dr. M. Moursi, who received 28% of the vote.  The second winner was Dr. A. Shafik, who received 24% of the vote.  The third winner was Mr. H. Sabahi, with 20% of the vote.  It also should be noted that Dr. A. Abou-el Fetouh and Mr. A. Mousa ranked fourth and fifth.  Both presidential candidates were ranked at the top prior to the election.

The result of the first round of elections was not anticipated by the majority of Egyptians, who expressed negative views and rejected the result. 

Many questions have been raised regarding the election results, especially about Dr. A. Shafik coming in second and being a candidate for the second round of elections on June 16th and 17th.

Protestors gathered in Midan al-Tahrir, objecting to Mr. Shafik as a possible president because he is viewed as an extension of the ex-Mubarak regime, which is considered a total violation of the objectives of the January 25th revolution.

Dr. A. Shafik was appointed as prime minister by ex-president Mubarak on January 29th, 2011, to crush the revolution, but this strategy failed.  Furthermore, Dr. Shafik was the minister of aviation in the previous cabinet.  He was considered a trusted and close friend of Mubarak.  Also, while as prime minister he facilitated the transfer of billions of dollars out of Egypt illegally.  Dr. Shafik’s hands are full of dirt and he should have been prevented from running for the position of president. 

The Egyptian parliament, prior to the election, passed a law preventing any members from the previous regime from running for a government position.  That law was sent to the Egyptian Constitutional Court to examine its legality and no decision was made regarding this.

I am of the opinion that Dr. Shafik is the candidate of the Egyptian Higher Military Council.  The military has been in power for 60 years and are not going to surrender many of the economic and political privileges that they enjoy.

There is no doubt that the Egyptian army protected the revolution during its first stage.  In reality, the revolution has succeeded in removing Mubarak and it put an end to the possibility of his son, Jamal, inheriting that position.  The army’s views on that possibility were well known – they objected to that scenario.  Nevertheless, after the removal of Mubarak on February 11, 2011, the Egyptian Higher Military Council, with the cooperation of the Muslim Brotherhood, developed a counter-revolution strategy to stop the demands of those who initiated the revolution and to curtail their influence.  This strategy was successful.  Both groups, the military council and the Muslim Brotherhood, have committed blunders that led to the instability of the political and economic situations that the country is facing.  For that reason and others, more than half of the Egyptians did not vote and the consequence of such actions led to the emergence of two undesired political candidates (Moursi and Shafik).  Both candidates ended up getting less than ¼ of the Egyptian vote.

The Egyptian mass media has been speculating about those who supported Dr. Shafik by referring to several groups with different rationales behind their decisions to cast their votes for Dr. Shafik.

1)   The majority of Egyptians Copts were fearful of political Islam’s control of Egypt and turning it into a conservative religion state.  Furthermore, Dr. Shafik publicly assured the group that if he is elected, he knows how to deal with Islamists.
2)   Many of the Mubarak supporters cast their votes for Dr. Shafik to protect their financial and political interests.  The election of Shafik, from their point of view, will be an extension of the Mubarak regime.
3)   Another group that didn’t participate in the previous election, many of them cast their votes for Dr. Shafik, because they were under the impression that the revolution brought instability, not security and safety, and their negative feelings regarding the increasing influence of political Islam played an influential role behind their support of Shafik.
4)   The money that was circulating, especially by advocates of Dr. Shafik, in popular neighborhoods where the poor reside, played a role in support of Shafik.  Also, many of these people are illiterate and lack the ability to make sound judgment in casting a vote.

There have been some demands made for the withdrawal of Dr. Shafik from the upcoming election, but that call will not be implemented.

Furthermore, other groups called on Dr. Moursi to withdraw from the election in favor of Mr. H. Sabahi, since the Islamists are in full control of the Egyptian parliament.  That call was also dismissed so far.  There is no doubt in my mind that the next two weeks of June 2012 might bring the unexpected.








May 21, 2012


The Ongoing Arab Spring Revolution


The Arab Spring Revolution is still an ongoing process, reflecting      democratic political progress, as is the case in Tunisia and Egypt.  On the other hand, political and military struggles are still going on in various forms, as is the case in Syria, where the regime is conducting a military civil war against its people.  No relief is in sight in Syria, except by the removal of Bashar al-Assad’s regime, which has already killed more than ten thousand Syrians.

The situation in Yemen reflects an ongoing struggle between the supporters of the previous Yemeni president, Ali Saleh, and the new transitional government, headed by A.R. Mansour.  Many of Ali Saleh’s relatives are still in important military positions and have refused to surrender their authority, which has led to a division and conflict in the Yemeni army.  This situation enhanced the emergence of al-Qaeda in southern Yemen, which is posing a threat to the security of the Arab Gulf states and the U.S.  This situation led President Obama to sign a new law, which will penalize any state that contributes to the instability of Yemen.  Furthermore, the U.S. military is helping the Yemeni military forces attack al-Qaeda’s forces in southern Yemen.  The Yemeni situation is more complicated than the presence of al-Qaeda there.  More than half of the Yemeni population is living below the poverty index level, and in addition, the unemployment rates are high.  Also, Yemen is among the world’s five states that are most water poverty stricken.  This has impacted the agriculture sector.  Yemen depends on food imports.  Yemen needs a comprehensive economic development program that will lead to the creation of new jobs, which will impact the strength and influence of al-Qaeda in Yemen.  The U.S. and the oil-producing Arab Gulf states could play a constructive role that will be more influential in defeating al-Qaeda.  This would be more effective than the current military strategy.

The Libyan situation is still in a state of reorganizing its political situation to bring harmony to the various political groups and tribal affiliations that will lead the country to its first free political election.

Egypt will experience its first free and democratic presidential election in a few days (May 23rd and 24th, 2012).  Regardless of who will be elected, the Egyptian political model will have an impact on the rest of the Arab world.

Apr 12, 2012

Arab Spring Revolution and Rise of Religious Sectarianism

The Spring Arab Revolution, which began in December 2010 in Tunisia and spread into Egypt, Yemen, Libya, Bahrain, and Syria with its main secular objective, has to remove the corrupt authoritarian regimes from power. The only successful state so far is Tunisia, which is on the right track to achieve its goal. In Egypt, the revolution has been stopped by a counter-revolution conducted by the Egyptian Higher Military Council and the Muslim Brotherhood. Both have achieved their first objective, which was the removal of Mubarak and a dozen of his associates from power. The military council is still part of the previous corrupt regime and its head, General Tantawi, was the defense minister for more than 25 years. The military council did their best after the removal of Mubarak to stop further changes, as the younger generation was demanding complete reform. The Muslim Brotherhood, which is the largest and most organized political group, has aligned themselves with the military council to achieve their political strategy. They have won the majority of seats in parliament and are pushing hard to dominate political power in Egypt. The latest strategy was the nomination of K. Al-Shater for the position of Egypt’s president, despite the fact that they announced previously on several occasions that they would not seek that position. The Muslim Brotherhood may have changed their slogan from “Islam is the solution” to “Lying is the solution”. The latest news (4/7/2012) revealed that Mr. K. al-Shater has been prevented from entering the race for the position of president for legal reasons. Also, two other candidates, Mr. Abon Ismail and Mr. A. Nour are under investigation for Egyptian law.

Furthermore, the nomination of Mr. O. Suleiman for the position of president is an open invitation for the previous regime to return to power. Remember, Mr. Suleiman was appointed as vice president by Mubarak. This nomination is a big blow to the Egyptian revolution. Mr. Suleiman will not win the election unless the military council rigs the election. The next few months might bring the unexpected.

Libya and Yemen are still involved in local conflicts, despite the removal of their previous corrupt regimes. Hopefully they might be able to overcome it.

The Syrian and Bahraini conflicts are drifting away from the secular political objectives and the uprisings are turning into religious-sectarian struggles between the Muslim Sunnis and Muslim Shiaa.

In Bahrain, the Sunnis, who are less than one-third of the population, are dominating the government. While the Shiaa majority has less than one half of the seats in parliament, the Syrian situation is totally the opposite, where the Alawites (a Shiaa offshoot who are a minority and less than 20% of the population) are dominating the nearly 70% Sunni population. The uprising in both countries, Syrian and Bahrain, is causing a political split among the Muslims states in the Middle East.

Iran, Iraq, and the Hezbollah Shiaa of Lebanon, led by Hassan Nasserallah, are supporting the regime in Syria and the Shiaa uprising in Bahrain. It is of interest to notice that the Lebanese political party, which established a reputation as the champion of the suppressed in the Arab world, turned to support the Assad regime in Syria against the Syrian uprising.

Furthermore, Prime Minister N. al-Maliki, who leads the Iraqi government, blasted the Saudi and Qatari governments for their support of the Syrian uprising against Assad’s regime. Both the Saudi and Qatari populations are dominated by a Sunni majority. Nevertheless, the mass media in both countries blasted Prime Minister al-Maliki and called him an agent of the Iranian government, which is dominated by a Shiaa population. It is also of interest to observe that the al-Maliki government’s sectarian policy has already caused a disenfranchisement of the country’s Sunni minority. A rift between al-Maliki’s government and his Sunni political opponents casts light on a growing sectarian divide in Iraqi politics.

It is also of interest to hear al-Maliki’s support of the Shiaa uprising in Bahrain and condemnation of the Sunni uprising in Syria. Furthermore, al-Maliki made it clear that the fall of the Syrian regime will have negative consequences on the entire Middle East region. The al-Maliki political stand was also echoed by Iran, where religious and political leaders warned against interference in the internal affairs of Syria.

The Syrian uprising is causing tensions between Turkey and Iran. Iran has a Shiaa majority population while Turkey has a dominant Sunni population. Turkey has condemned the Syrian regime atrocity against its people and has been playing an important role in hosting an international meeting for the Syrian opposition group. Iran accused Turkey of being a supporter of the U.S. and Zionist Israel.

Iran has been the major source of military supply to Syria and its major political supporter. Furthermore, several Sunni Arab states, especially in the Gulf area, have already stated publicly that they are ready to supply the Syrian Free Army with weapons to help the removal of Bashar al-Assad and his government from power. The irony of such public support coming from the Saudi government is that this government discriminates and has been suppressing the Saudi Shiaa minority for hundreds of years.

The rise of religious sectarianism between the Sunni majority versus the Muslim Shiaa minority has been a major historical conflict in the Arab world in particular and the Islamic world in general for more than a thousand years.

Apr 7, 2012

The Dilemma of the Proposed New Egyptian Constitution

During the past few weeks, the battle for drafting the new Egyptian constitution has reached its peak. There are three major camps and each one has its own agenda in terms of what the constitution should or should not include.

The first camp is reflected in the Egyptian Higher Military Council with the most political power and influence. Their hidden agenda is to include in the new constitution their right to prevent the parliament and future government from interfering in their military budget and economic investments under the pretext of national security.

It was reported that the military council has issued a public warning that nobody should interfere in their economic projects, and that provisions should be included in the new constitution permitting that. Furthermore, no civil authority should manage any of their economic projects. The military council will not permit any civilian interference in their economic affairs. The members of the military council pointed out that the return from their investment, which is equal to 1.2 billion Egyptian pounds per year, is subject to control by the government accounting department. However, the army does not pay taxes on that income. The military council issued a warning that any pressure from the Egyptian parliament might lead to undesirable consequences. (Aljazeera.net, 3/30/2012). Keep in mind that the military has been in power for more than 60 years and are not going to give it up easily.

The second camp is reflected in the political Islamic parties, which includes the Freedom and Justice Party, the Nour-Salafi Party, and Al-Jamat il-Islamiyah. The three political Islamic groups have won more than 70% of the parliament seats. As a result of that victory, they are demanding to send 50 members from their parliament to join the 100-member committee that is supposed to draft the new constitution. The political Islamic group has already declared its belief that the new constitution should include, among other things, that Islam is the religion of the state and that Sharia is the fundamental source of its judicial law.

It was also reported that the military council has issued hidden threats to dissolve the parliament, which is illegal according to the Islamicists. However, the military council has the power to do so.

The third camp consists of all secular political parties, as well as the younger generation who were the vanguard of the Egyptian revolution. The group’s main objective is to draft a new constitution that will state that Egypt is an Arab Muslim country with a secular government that will be free and democratically elected. All citizens will be treated equally.

Nearly all independent and liberal members who were asked to serve on the committee to draft the new constitution have resigned in protest of the expected domination of the committee by Islamicists. Even the Alazhar University representative has joined the group in protest as well. The parliament has selected 50 members to join the committee, which will consist of 100 people who are expected to draft the constitution. Only 75 members of the committee showed up to the first meeting with the military council. No decision was made yet. (as of 3/24/2012)

So far, there has been no agreement among the three camps in terms of their views about the new constitution. Furthermore, all of the experts in constitutional law and other members of judicial knowledge have resigned from the committee, which is supposed to include 100 people that will be responsible for drafting the new constitution.

The Muslim Brotherhood (the Freedom and Justice Party) should learn from the Tunisian Model. The Tunisian Islamic Party “Al-Nahda” was the biggest winner in the election, but their leader, R. al-Khanoushi, compromised with other secular political parties in drafting their new constitution. The new Tunisian constitution kept the first part of the previous constitution, without any changes. It states that “Tunis is a free and independent state and Islam is its religion and Arabic is its language and its form of government is a republic”. No reference was made to Sharia law, and it should be noted that the literacy rate in Tunisia is around 85%, while the literacy rate in Egypt is nearly 62%. It has been mentioned that most of those who voted for the Islamic parties were illiterate. The Egyptian Freedom and Justice Islamic political party should learn from both the Tunisian and the Turkish Islamic political models.

Apr 3, 2012

The Dilemma of the Proposed New Egyptian Constitution

During the past few weeks, the battle for drafting the new Egyptian constitution has reached its peak. There are three major camps and each one has its own agenda in terms of what the constitution should or should not include.

The first camp is reflected in the Egyptian Higher Military Council with the most political power and influence. Their hidden agenda is to include in the new constitution their right to prevent the parliament and future government from interfering in their military budget and economic investments under the pretext of national security.

It was reported that the military council has issued a public warning that nobody should interfere in their economic projects, and that provisions should be included in the new constitution permitting that. Furthermore, no civil authority should manage any of their economic projects. The military council will not permit any civilian interference in their economic affairs. The members of the military council pointed out that the return from their investment, which is equal to 1.2 billion Egyptian pounds per year, is subject to control by the government accounting department. However, the army does not pay taxes on that income. The military council issued a warning that any pressure from the Egyptian parliament might lead to undesirable consequences. (Aljazeera.net, 3/30/2012). Keep in mind that the military has been in power for more than 60 years and are not going to give it up easily.

The second camp is reflected in the political Islamic parties, which includes the Justice and Freedom Party, the Nour-Salafi Party, and Al-Jamat il-Islamiyah. The three political Islamic groups have won more than 70% of the parliament seats. As a result of that victory, they are demanding to send 50 members from their parliament to join the 100-member committee that is supposed to draft the new constitution. The political Islamic group has already declared its belief that the new constitution should include, among other things, that Islam is the religion of the state and that Sharia is the fundamental source of its judicial law.

It was also reported that the military council has issued hidden threats to dissolve the parliament, which is illegal according to the Islamicists. However, the military council has the power to do so.

The third camp consists of all secular political parties, as well as the younger generation who were the vanguard of the Egyptian revolution. The group’s main objective is to draft a new constitution that will state that Egypt is an Arab Muslim country with a secular government that will be free and democratically elected. All citizens will be treated equally.

Nearly all independent and liberal members who were asked to serve on the committee to draft the new constitution have resigned in protest of the expected domination of the committee by Islamicists. Even the Alazhar representatives have joined the group in protest as well. The parliament has selected 50 members to join the committee, which will consist of 100 people who are expected to draft the constitution. Only 75 members of the committee showed up to the first meeting with the military council. No decision was made yet. (as of 3/24/2012)

So far, there has been no agreement among the three camps in terms of their views about the new constitution. Furthermore, experts in constitutional law and other members of judicial knowledge have resigned from the committee, which is supposed to include 100 people that will be responsible for drafting the new constitution.

The Muslim Brotherhood (the Freedom and Justice Party) should learn from the Tunisian Model. The Tunisian Islamic Party “Al-Nahda” was the biggest winner in the election, but their leader, R. al-Khanoushi, compromised with other secular political parties in drafting their new constitution. The new Tunisian constitution kept the first part of the previous constitution, without any changes. It states that “Tunis is a free and independent state and Islam is its religion and Arabic is its language and its form of government is a republic”. No reference was made to Sharia law, and it should be noted that the literacy rate in Tunisia is around 85%, while the literacy rate in Egypt is nearly 62%. It has been mentioned that most of those who voted for the Islamic parties were illiterate. The Egyptian Freedom and Justice Islamic political party should learn from both the Tunisian and the Turkish Islamic political models.

Apr 1, 2012

The Blunder of the Saudi Fatwa

Recently, the international press reported on a new fatwa issued by the Saudi Arabian Mufti, Shah Abed al-Aziz Al-Ishaih who called for the demolition of all Christian churches in the Gulf region and the prevention of the construction of new ones. (www.almasry-alyoum.com, 3/25/12).

Such an irresponsible religious fatwa by one of the highest Islamic religious officials in Saudi Arabia is a slap on the face for the Saudi king, who has been personally advocating a peaceful coexistence among the three monotheistic religions – Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.

The fatwa by the Saudi Mufti has created international protests by Christian religious leaders in several western countries and Russia.

As of March 30th, 2012, I have not read any official reactions from the Saudi government regarding the fatwa. Keep in mind that there are over 3 million Christian foreign workers in Qatar, the Emirates, Yemen, Oman, and Bahrain who are entitled to practice their religious beliefs freely.

The Saudi religious leader who issued the “fatwa” must be ignorant of the content of the Quran that refers positively to the followers of the holy books “Christians and Jews”.

Furthermore, such an irresponsible religious statement will further fuel the discrimination against Islam and Muslims, especially in the U.S. and other western countries. Every religion tends to have its own share of ignorant and fanatic people who will take advantage of any opportunity to discriminate against the members of other faiths. Such fanatic and un-enlightened people want to be the authority on earth to judge other people and ignore the basic teachings of their own religions, such as that God is the only judge.

It is unfortunate to say that throughout history in all of the three monotheistic religions, some religious leaders want to interpret religion the way they want it to be and not the way it is written in the holy books.

In democratic and open societies, the matter of constructing places of worship is the responsibility of the civil authorities and not the religious ones, especially in terms of building zoning codes and safety in addition to the practice of religion.

The Wahabi religious hierarchy in Saudi Arabia is living in total isolation in terms of the changes that have been taking place worldwide. They should learn a lesson from the influences of the Arab Islamic civilization on the world more than one thousand years ago. May the all mighty open the eyes of these fanatics in Saudi Arabia to see the light and protect Islam from their fanaticism.

Mar 25, 2012

Water Shortage in the Arab World - Its Negative Consequences

During the past several years, I have focused on the shortages of fresh water in the Arab world. Nearly all Arab states have fallen below the minimal water need, which is 700 cu.met/person/year according to the U.N. standard. Several Arab states have even fell below the 500 cu.met./person/year , as is the case especially in Jordan and Yemen which are classified among the most water poverty stricken countries.

Furthermore, the shortages of water will get even worse in light of several factors: 1) if the population increases at the same rate, the Arab world population will double from 365 million as of 2011 to nearly over 650 million in the next 25-30 years. According to a recent U.N. report, the consumption of water increased six fold during the last century, while the world population increased three fold during the same period.

2) The global climate changes that have been taking place, which have impacted North Africa and the Middle East region more than any region around the globe. The increase in temperature and the decrease in the annual rainfall led to the frequent droughts in many parts of the Arab world, which lasted in some countries for more than 6-7 years. This also led to more desertification of land. Keep in mind that more than 75% of the land in the Arab world is barren desert that is unsuitable for cultivation. It is unfortunate that urban expansion in the Arab world takes place on agricultural lands, especially in Egypt.

3) The three major rivers that flow in the Arab world – the Nile, the Euphrates, and the Tigress – originate beyond the boundaries of the Arab world. Most of the lands under cultivation depend on rainfall.

4) Nearly 70% of the water in the Arab world is used for agricultural cultivation. The old system of irrigation is still the major method used for cultivation, despite the fact that the flow of water in the three major rivers in the Arab world has been decreasing.

5) The Arab world is considered the number one region in the import of cereal in the world. Recently, it was reported that more than 65 million tons of wheat were imported during 2011. Furthermore, from 2007-2010, food imports increased by 13%.

6) None of the 22 Arab states is sufficient in food production. More than 50% of the food consumed in the Arab world is imported from abroad. The cost of food import has been estimated to exceed $35 billion per year.

Such information is available to the political leadership in the Arab world and they have been discussing it through the regular Arab league meetings. It is regrettable to say that aside from the discussion as usual, no concrete policy has been implemented and put into action regarding the future and present threats of starvation, which millions of people in the Arab world will face. Nearly half of the population in the Arab world is poverty-stricken. Recent reports by the CIA and the U.N. revealed that “by the year 2040, the world will face a shortage of fresh water. The situation will lead to political unrest and will hinder economic growth and will endanger the availability of food in the global market.” Furthermore, the U.N. has issued a report warning the Arab world in particular, who uses 70% of its water resources for cultivation despite the fact that it imports more than 50% of its food needs. The report continued to project that war caused by shortages of water will not lead to armed conflict in the Middle East. However, the situation will lead to political and economic manipulation among neighbor states. (www.nytimes.com, 3/23/2012).

In conclusion, and despite the recommendations issued by various Arab league committees about the present and future threats of water shortages and its impact on food needs, it is unfortunate to say that Arab political leadership has failed to take the warning seriously. Arab oil producing countries, especially in the Gulf region, are short sighted. They have invested over two trillion dollars in foreign countries, especially in the west. They have failed to invest even 10% of their foreign investments in the Arab world, especially in the countries with high populations, like Egypt and others where nearly half the population are living below the poverty index levels. In addition, such an investment will also create millions of jobs for the many young people who are unemployed.

I would like to stress again the fact that the Arab Spring Revolution started by the young Arab college graduates. Many are unemployed. Furthermore, the impact of that revolution has been felt by the entire Arab population, irrespective of where they live. It is about time that Arab wealth is invested in the Arab world, where the challenges are so serious they cannot be ignored.

Mar 20, 2012

The First Anniversary of the January 25, 2011 Egyptian Revolution

Two months ago (Jan. 2012) my wife and I traveled back to Egypt and were happy to participate as eyewitnesses to the first anniversary of the Egyptian revolution (2/11/2012). During the two months in Cairo, we met with friends and relatives. We also visited the American University campus and talked with old colleagues and some students. We were invited to participate in an open discussion with some young people who were among the activists in Tahrir Square, as well as with some members of the Kifayah Party. Personally, I was interested in getting people’s reactions and views of the revolution’s accomplishments during its first year, since the collapse of the previous corrupt regime.

There is no doubt that the Egyptian revolution was a major accomplishment for the Egyptian people, who were harshly suppressed for more than three decades. The young generation who led the revolution were born during the corrupt rule of Hosni Mubarak. They have seen and experienced how Egypt was run by a small mafia who were associated with the regime that controlled the country politically, economically, and even religiously, with an iron fist.

The younger generation has seen Egypt as a satellite for the U.S. and Israeli governments and being marginalized politically and economically in the Middle East in general and the Arab world in particular.

Nevertheless, during the past year, Egypt began to regain its traditional role as the leader of the Arab world and an active major power in the Middle East region. There are other major accomplishments that took place during the first year after the revolution. The following changes occurred:

1) A new and freely elected parliament for the first time since the 1950s. Also a freely elected Shura Council.

2) A new date has been set for the election of a new president. This will be the first president in the history of Egypt. On March 10, 2012, the official nomination for candidates for the position of president began. By the end of June, the newly elected president will assume his role officially.

3) Nearly a dozen or more high-ranking public officials have been prosecuted and received jail sentences. Others, such as Mubarak, his two sons, and others, are waiting for the court to announce its verdict on June 2, 2012.

These are among the major accomplishments that took place since the fall of the previous regime. In the mean time, not all objectives of the revolution have been completed yet. The expected reforms are being stalled due to the influence of the Egyptian Higher Military Council, who has failed to push for the drastic reforms the younger generation is calling for. The younger generation has been marginalized for the benefit of the old political parties. It is no longer a hidden fact that the Muslim Brotherhood struck a deal with the Egyptian Higher Military Council to accommodate each other’s political objectives.

In the mean time, the influence of the previous regime still exists, which has been experienced in different types of counter revolutionary acts. The latest was the Port Said massacre, and prior to that similar counter revolutionary acts took place, such as the Masparo attacks, the Mohammad Mahmoud Street, the Ministry of Interior, and the Prime Minister’s headquarters. All of these attacks were referred to by security as acts committed by a third group.

The Egyptian Higher Military Council has failed to cleanse the system from the influence of the previous regime. An example of this is the Ministry of Interior, which experienced the appointments of three ministers in one year. The police and security are not visible in the streets, and the Baltagiah (hoodlums) have a free hand in robbing people, banks, and in some cases blocking main roads to steal. Cars are a major target of theft, where some people can retrieve their stolen cars by paying a certain sum of money set by the thieves. The Ministry of Interior, as well as the judicial system, needs to be cleansed from those who were appointed by the previous regime.

There is no doubt that the Egyptian revolution, despite the negative consequences, is still viewed as a major success by comparison to other revolutions. The Egyptian revolution, which was backed by military forces that protected the people, was a major contribution to the collapse of the Mubarak regime. The first stage of the revolution was a total success.

However, the stages that followed reflect that the Egyptian Higher Military council was not ready to surrender their authority for a civilian one. After all, they have been in power for the last sixty years, and were part of the previous corrupt regime. Many of the problems that Egyptian society has been experiencing since the fall of the previous regime could have been avoided. The military council should have appointed a civilian transitional president to prepare for a smooth transition focused on the following:

1) The drafting of a new constitution by legal experts, especially academics in constitutional law. This could have voided the conflict that has been going on by those who have won the majority in parliament.

2) The election of the members of parliament should have been based on equal representation that reflects the demographic composition of the Egyptian population in terms of the gender ratio and adequate representation the Coptic community.

A quick look at the result of the election of the Egyptian parliament reflects an insult to democracy and common sense. Fifty percent of the Egyptian population consists of women. Only 8 women were elected out of the more than 505 members. How many Copts were elected? How many young people, who were the vanguard of the revolution, were elected?

These are among the major mistakes the members of the Egyptian Higher Military Council have committed. We hope that the future civilian government will assume real power to rectify some of the political mistakes that were made during the transitional period. The political model that will emerge in Egypt will have an important impact on the rest of the Arab world.

Netanyahu’ s Belligerent War Demands

At the recent AIPAC annual convention in Washington, President Obama addressed the audience and assured them of the U.S.’s continuous support of Israel. The second major speaker was the Israeli Prime Minister, B. Netanyahu, who focused on Iranian nuclear threats to Israel. He stressed the need for the U.S. to join Israel and bomb Iran’s nuclear reactor. However, President Obama stressed a more diplomatic approach.

During the past three years, the relationship between both men has been cold due to the lack of cooperation in solving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Mr. Netanyahu refused to freeze the construction of Jewish settlements as a pre-condition to starting peace negotiations with the Palestinians. Furthermore, Mr. Netanyahu snubbed President Obama on several occasions and, as usual, gets the automatic political support from the majority of members of the U.S. Congress. These members put Israeli interest ahead of American national interest.

Mr. Netanyahu’s strategy is to pressure President Obama to join the war against Iran and spread negative remarks that will lead to the president’s defeat in the upcoming election. All the Republican presidential candidates (with the exception of Ron Paul) support Netanyahu’s aggressive policy. The tragedy of such a reaction on the part of American politicians is the fact that the majority of the Israeli population is against bombing Iran’s nuclear reactors. The Haaretz Newspaper revealed that 58% of Israelis are against the attack and only 26% are supportive (N.Y.T., 3/14/12).

Furthermore, it was reported that many Israeli politicians, academics, and high-ranking military leaders, including the previous Mossad chief Meir Dagan, are rejecting Netanyahu’s war policy and think it will be more dangerous to Israel than it is for Iran to have a nuclear bomb. It is very strange to see that Netanyahu’s strategy is being supported by AIPAC, Jewish Zionist organizations, and the American neocon groups, and that they are calling for the bombing of Iran’s nuclear reactors.

The Washington Post (3/12/12) revealed that Krouthammer, who represents the super-hawk wing of the Post’s neocon-dominated editorial section, took special umbrage with a background quote one of Obama’s advisors who said, “We are trying to make the decision to attack as a hard as possible for Israel.” Krouthammer deemed that remark “revealing and shocking”.

The article continued to state that for Krouthammer, Obama’s only right answer to Netanyahu’s belligerent demands who have been a blank check to be paid for by the American military and U.S. taxpayers.

It seems that the American Zionist neocons have failed to learn a lesson from their previous reckless and completely iniquitous political strategies when they pushed the U.S. to go to war in both Afghanistan and Iraq for the benefit of Israel. Their strategies have been based on false and fabricated reports to mislead the American people. The reports were not investigated and were accepted by the majority of the members of the American Congress.

It is unfortunate to say that the politically illiterate Americans end up paying a heavy price physically and financially in both wars. More than six thousand American soldiers have died in vain and more than 40,000 have been injured. In addition, there is the financial cost, which has been estimated to exceed 4 trillion dollars in taxpayer money. As Professor J. Stiglitz, a Nobel Prize winner, puts it: it was the first war in the history of the U.S. that was fought on a credit card.

Mr. Netanyahu and his supporters in the U.S. have no concern about the American national interest. What the U.S. president should do is address the American people about the campaign conducted against him by the supporters of Mr. Netanyahu’s war policy. Recent polls reflect a negative reaction against President Obama due to the increase in oil prices. The president should address the American public and explain that situation of oil price increases is attributed to the threat of Netanyahu bombing Iran’s nuclear reactors and that the Wall Street speculators and gamblers who take advantage of such situations as usual in order to make a rapid and hefty profit. After all, the oil-producing countries have nothing to do with oil price increases.

Two years ago, similar things occurred when the oil prices reached $4 per gallon. The issue was raised by the press and members of congress promised to investigate the oil price increases. Later, it was reported that congress came up with a plan to deal with such situations, but they never implemented their decision. It is unfortunate to say that the majority of the members of congress will align themselves with the devil if it ensures their re-elections.

In conclusion, Mr. Netanyahu’s policy about the threat of Iran’s nuclear bomb to Israel is to distract the Israeli and the world public opinion from what is going on in Israel, and to cover Netanyahu’s failures and aggressive behavior toward the Palestinians. Israeli expansion in the occupied Palestinian lands continues with the blessing of American politicians.

Mar 6, 2012

The Kneeling Egyptian Pharaoh

A caricature appeared in the Egyptian media, showing the Egyptian Pharaoh kneeling in front of the American Statue of Liberty. What this really means is the fact that the Egyptian government has caved to the American government’s demands and released the 19 Americans who were accused of violating Egyptian law. The case was taken away from the Egyptian Criminal Court and the 19 Americans accused were bailed out and permitted to leave Egypt on an American military plane that landed at Cairo airport without permit.

This incident enraged the Egyptians. It led to a protest movement in front of the American embassy in Cairo.

The speaker of the Egyptian parliament, Dr. El Katatny, promised an investigation of this interference in the Egyptian judicial system to find out who are the responsible people involved in the case. He set March 11th, 2012, as a special Parliament session to investigate the case.

Meanwhile, the Egyptian mass media has been focusing on this case and accusing the most powerful political groups - the Egyptian Higher Military Council and the Muslim Brotherhood.

I regrettably maintain that the Egyptian Revolution has been stolen, despite the free election of a new parliament and the Shura Council. Many of the revolutionary demands have not been implemented yet and Egypt is entering a dark tunnel that might lead to another revolution.

One of the major demands of the revolution was the restoration of Egypt freedom and dignity from foreign interferences, especially by the American government.

The release of the American accused individuals reflects the fact that Egypt is still under the thumb of American’s government influence. The later has been threatening to cut US foreign Aid to Egypt. For those who are not aware of the details of American Aid, I would like to point out the fact that the US benefits more from the aids than Egypt.

Second, American politicians in general are not well informed about the relation between countries that the US is dealing with, especially in the Middle East region and in particular the Arab world.

Many politicians are short sighted and tend to fall under the pressure of lobbyists who represent interest groups and multi-National Co-operations whose financial contributions is essential for their re-elections. The consequences of such American foreign policy are harmful in the long run to the American national interests. Also it produces negative reactions in foreign countries where the US is involved. There is no doubt that every country looks after its own national interest. However, when the interest is shared with other countries ‘ national interests, it would contribute to political stability, which will be of beneficial to all. Unfortunately, the US, political interferences in the Arab world, especially during the past six decades has been un-democratic and supportive of corrupt authoritarian regimes.

Frequently, American politicians use the rational that its aim is to spread democracy This is a justification for their interferences in the internal affairs of other countries as was the case for the invasion of Iraq in 2003. The Christian Science Monitor recently stated that there is no democracy in Iraq. It is only on paper and is not being implemented. The American public tends to fall for such rational.

The three American organizations that went to Egypt to help Egyptian and prepare them to ‘practice democracy’ should have done this in the US instead of Egypt.

It is of interest to read some of the remarks made recently by the Senator from Maine, Olympia Snowe. She stated that after 40 years in the Senate she is not seeking re-election. One of the major rational she used is that “the Senate is not living up to what the Founding Fathers envisioned”, and if “the people in the US raise their voices, they will solve the nation’s most urgent challenges”

America’s challenges at home is more threatening to its security, than the challenges abroad.